Jill Barth
Middle managers have become the unsung heroes of the workplace after steering the ship through the disruption of the pandemic and the culture changes brought on by shifts in remote work. However, HR leaders must be aware that they are increasingly becoming the most vulnerable workforce population. Far from the glamorous leadership roles portrayed in corporate narratives, today’s managers are navigating an unprecedented scene of challenges that threaten their professional effectiveness—and their very wellbeing.
Middle managers and workplace dynamics
Mike Dolen, CEO of manager support platform Humancore and former HR executive at Home Depot and IBM, warns of a looming crisis in middle management burnout. He points to companies flattening hierarchies during layoffs, which leaves middle managers with fewer peers, increased workloads and greater pressure to perform.
Recent research in LinkedIn’s Work Change Report: AI is Coming to Work provides insights into what business leaders want from their workforce. The report reveals that 80% of C-suite executives believe AI will kickstart a culture shift where teams are more innovative. However, the blend of AI and human skills is a key marker of adaptability and growth, yet remains hard to find, according to LinkedIn.
Global HR leaders struggle to source management-level talent with the right mix of technical and soft skills. This technological revolution is expected to reshape how managers operate, adding layers of complexity to their already challenging roles.
The ‘manager’s dilemma’
The AI-driven transformation of work has been swift, says Dolen. Technological disruption has converged with pandemic-induced restructuring and rapidly changing workforce expectations to create a perfect storm for middle management. Dolen describes this phenomenon as a “manager’s dilemma.”
The numbers tell a stark story of increasing complexity. In a July 2024 Gartner survey of 805 HR leaders, 75% said managers are overwhelmed by expanding responsibilities, and 69% noted that managers are not equipped to lead change. This compression creates a strain on managers who are expected to do more with less.
Meanwhile, Dolen says, the role of a manager has expanded beyond traditional oversight responsibilities. Today’s middle managers are expected to be mental health supporters, career coaches, cultural architects and change management experts, he says.
In many organizations, Dolen adds, managers also must simultaneously navigate hybrid work environments, bridge generational workplace differences and maintain team productivity. Continue reading